Healthcare
Facilities
Indoor
Air Quality Problems in Healthcare Facilities
Introduction
Healthcare
facilities, such as hospitals, have to pay particular care to
indoor air concerns. Many of those who are susceptible to
these problems may be patients such as people with
pre-existing health problems, the frail elderly, people with
cancer who are going through treatment, and those who may have
depressed immune systems. Some hospitals also have special
units that need particular care in terms of indoor air quality
such as bone marrow units, neonatal intensive care units, and
burn units. In addition to having people inside the building
who are at risk to these problems, there are some unique
indoor air concerns in healthcare facilities including those
usually found in buildings. These include:
Infectious
Diseases and Other Biological Hazards
Biological
contaminants such as bacteria, mold, and viruses can breed in
stagnant water that has gradually accumulated in ducts,
humidifiers and drain pans of the ventilation system; or water
that has collected on ceiling tiles, carpeting, or insulation.
This is particularly a problem in older buildings that may
have broken fans or other maintenance problems. Such
maintenance problems may be common since many healthcare
facilities are always looking for ways to save money.1
All parts of the humidification and dehumidification systems
must be kept clean and dry to prevent growth of bacteria and
fungi. Otherwise, microorganisms, such as Aspergillus
spores, can become airborne and infect patients who have
suppressed immune systems. Moisture in other areas may also
contribute to the growth of mold from increased humidity. For
example, certain respiratory care equipment produces a lot of
mist, which can increase the humidity levels in a room. These
rooms need to be cleaned particularly well to prevent the
growth of mold.
Hospitals have
to take special precautions to prevent infections from
spreading. As it is, 5% of all patients who go to hospitals
for treatment will develop an infection while they are there.2
However, it is not only patients or residents in these
facilities who are at risk. Healthcare workers have a higher
risk than most people of being infected by airborne or
bloodborne diseases. For example, healthcare workers who work
at facilities in cities have positive tuberculosis (TB) skin
tests (meaning they have been exposed to the TB bacteria)
about eight times more often than the rest of the US
population. In addition, at least 17 healthcare workers have
developed drug-resistant TB as a result of working in these
environments.3
Because
patients have infections that can spread through the air,
there must be proper ventilation. In the case of airborne
infectious diseases like TB, patients are often kept in
special isolation rooms that are under negative pressure so
that contaminated air will not get out of the room. This type
of isolation is called infectious isolation. However, often
people who may be infectious may not be diagnosed right away
so those in emergency rooms (ER) are most at risk.
To minimize
this risk, some hospitals are taking steps to design their
facilities to try to prevent the spread of infectious diseases
in the ER. For example, when the Children's Hospital in Fort
Worth, Texas redesigned their ER in 1996, they had the rooms
designed to decrease the chance of airborne transmission of
diseases. To begin with, they designed the waiting room where
the air swept through the room and decreased the chances of
any mixing of the room air. If somebody has an infectious
disease that gets into the air and there is mixing of the room
air, there is a good chance that others in the room will also
breathe in that infected air. Once the air passes through the
waiting room to the return air duct, it passes through a HEPA
filter. These filters trap particles bigger than 0.3 µm
(micrometers) in diameter. Most bacteria are 0.5 to 10 um and
TB is 1 to 5 so these filters should capture any infectious
organisms in the air. By using the HEPA filter in the return
duct, the hospital saves money by not having to have the room
totally exhausted to the outside since this is not a high-risk
area. If there are patients who come in who have signs or
symptoms of an infectious disease, they are put in a separate
room that does have 100% exhaust to the outside so there is no
chance of the air returning to the hospital. These rooms can
also be put under negative pressure so infected air from
inside of them won't get out into spaces like hallways.4
For high-risk
patients, like those whose immune systems are compromised,
there may be special rooms that are under positive pressure in
which fresh air flows into the room and there is positive
pressure built up so that no contaminants can come in from the
outside. These rooms are called protective isolation rooms
since they are designed to protect the patient. One important
contaminant in the air that these at risk patients are being
protected from is fungi.
One researcher
calculated that about 9% of reported hospital infections
between 1986 and 1990 were caused by fungi.5
However, for these rooms to be effective in preventing
infections like this, it is very important that the air
filters in the ventilation system be changed often. That is
because filters are an ideal location for fungus to grow. In
one study, nine of 11 air filters that had been in use less
than 1 month showed fungal growth on them. These filters had
been taken from different air handling units on different
dates. The two filters that did not have growth on them had
been treated with an antimicrobial agent; however, the
untreated cardboard frames around the filter media had
extensive fungal growth.6 One bone marrow unit
learned the hard way about the importance of cleaning filters
when a 6-year-old patient developed pneumonitis and died. The
child's autopsy showed that the child had been infected with Aspergillus
fumigatus. When investigators found that staff on the unit
were also suffering some health problems, they inspected the
air filters on the bone marrow unit, which were found to be
completely clogged with high levels of Aspergillus
fumigatus.7
Chemical
Hazards
Just like in
other buildings there can be many chemical hazards such as
volatile organic compounds from adhesives, furnishings,
manufactured wood products, copy machines, pesticides,
cleaning agents, and tobacco smoke. Contaminants from the
outside such as motor vehicle exhaust can get into the
ventilation system. To prevent the spread of infections,
housekeeping staff often use cleaning chemicals such as
disinfectants to help keep the healthcare facilities clean. In
addition, since patients are sleeping in hospitals and nursing
facilities at night, cleaning is often done during the day,
which means more people may be exposed to the vapors from the
chemicals. However, hospitals also have unusual chemical
hazards also. For example, some lab tests in healthcare
facilities require the use of solvents such as acetone,
benzene, formaldehyde, xylenes, methylene chloride, and
toluene.
There are also chemicals used
to disinfect medical equipment such as glutaraldehyde and
ethylene oxide (which can cause cancer). Glutaraldehyde is a
common contributor to IAQ problems. Though there are standards
saying what levels of exposure should be safe for this
chemical, some people have reactions at low levels. That is
what happened in the endoscopy unit at one hospital. Though
air monitoring showed that the levels should have been at
concentrations considered safe, some of the people working
there were still having problems. Investigators recommended
additional exhaust ventilation and eye and face protection for
employees who work with the solution.1
Certain drugs that can
accidentally get into the air, such as anesthetic gases from
operating rooms, can also be hazardous. One anesthetic gas,
nitrous oxide (often found in some dental offices), has been
linked to spontaneous abortions in female staff who are
continuously exposed to it. Other drugs can be quite toxic and
require special ventilation. One example is aerosolized
medications like pentamidine, which may be given for
conditions like pneumonia associated with AIDS. ASHRAE
requires that these treatments must be given in rooms with
increased ventilation. Certain chemotherapy drugs used to
fight cancer are also very toxic and need to be prevented from
getting into the air.
Latex gloves, which first
became very common in hospitals in the 1980s with the increase
in AIDS, HIV, and other bloodborne diseases, began causing
latex allergies in healthcare workers. The main problem was
not so much the latex in the glove itself, but the powder. The
latex protein molecules can bind with the cornstarch powder on
the outside and inside of gloves. The powder on the outside
keeps them from getting stuck to each other in the box and the
powder on the inside of the gloves makes them easier to put
on. When gloves are pulled out of the box, some of the powder
with the latex molecules gets into the air as it does when
gloves are removed. Once in the air, the latex dust can float
and be inhaled by people within a large area, putting them at
risk of an allergic reaction.
A growing number of healthcare
workers, as well as the public at large, have latex allergies.
This can result in health problems ranging from skin
irritations to potentially fatal breathing problems. Estimates
indicate that up to 6% of the general population and 10% or
more of healthcare workers have latex allergies.8,9
Consequently, many hospitals have been changing over to using
non-latex sterile gloves like nitrile. However, latex is found
almost everywhere. One of the newest prohibitions in
"latex-safe" hospitals has been to prohibit latex
balloons. Originally, latex balloons were banned only in many
children's hospitals because they shrunk when deflated and
could possibly be swallowed. It is only in the past couple of
years that hospitals have begun banning latex balloons. That
is because latex balloons are some of the most allergenic
latex products made and these allergens can get into the air.
Instead, hospitals recommend mylar balloons. These are the
ones with the shiny, metallic look. Though mylar balloons can
cost anywhere from 2-5 times more than latex balloons, they
last much longer, have messages printed on them, and do not
cause reactions in people allergic to latex.10
Many long-term care facilities
use carpeting. To help the carpeting last as long as possible,
these facilities should work with a cleaning service in
setting up a routine maintenance program to prevent problems
before they occur. Though this may cost money in the short
term, it saves money in the long term by not having to replace
the carpet as often. However, they need to do their homework
to find out what preventive care the flooring will need ahead
of time so that businesses will not take advantage. One
healthcare facility had been told by one company that they
would have to strip and refinish their floors every two weeks.
With proper routine maintenance, stripping may not be required
for years at a time!11 Though manufacturers are
producing carpeting that is easier to clean, it still needs to
be kept clean and dry to prevent mold and mildew from
triggering allergic reactions. It is also good to use cleaning
methods that avoid putting a lot of moisture into the
carpeting. If a cleaning service is coming in, their workers
should have been trained about any chemicals they use so they
do not overuse them.11
One of the best ways to improve
indoor air in a healthcare facility is to purchase
environmentally friendly products that do not contribute to
indoor air pollution. For example, Kaiser Permanente no longer
buys mercury thermometers or mercury blood pressure equipment.
Hartford Hospital also decided to switch over to mercury-free,
latex-free blood pressure equipment, which has meant fewer
mercury spills. This translates into a savings since there are
no longer the associated cleanup costs.12 There is
also no longer the risk of the toxic exposure of people to the
mercury. Other healthcare facilities have all stopped using
mercury-containing products unless there are no reasonable
alternatives available. Some healthcare facilities have also
begun recycling their fluorescent lights and have switched
most routine glove purchases from latex to nitrile gloves.
Hospitals may also buy recycled solvents for their
laboratories instead of brand new ones.12
To find out more about
healthier alternatives for hospitals, consult the following
resources:
- American Society for
Healthcare Environmental Services: (312) 422-3860; www.ashes.org
- The Sustainable Hospitals
Project at the University of Massachusetts at Lowell lists
alternatives for products that otherwise would contain
latex, mercury, or PVC with manufacturer contact
information: (978) 934-3386; www.uml.edu/centers/LCSP/hospitals/
- The State of Massachusetts
Office of Technical Assistance publishes a bimonthly
newsletter called the Health Care Environmentally
Preferable Purchasing (EPP) Network Information Exchange
Bulletin: www.state.ma.us/ota/otapubs.htm#eppnet
Unique
Ventilation Requirements
The purpose of ventilation is
to assist in providing a safe, comfortable and healthy
environment for the patients and staff in a healthcare
facility. In Europe, the trend is toward more natural
ventilation, with windows that open. In the U.S. if a hospital
is mechanically ventilated, it must be with 100% outside air.
How much air and how clean depends on the part of the
hospital. For example, operating rooms require 30 cfm per
person according to the ASHRAE requirements for healthcare
facilities. In addition, HEPA-filters and ultraviolet
germicidal irradiation lights may be used since there are
often large open wounds exposed for long periods.13
ASHRAE has a handbook that
gives specific ventilation requirements for different parts of
the hospital. For example, they have specific requirements for
ventilation and filtration to dilute and remove contamination
such as airborne microorganisms and viruses, hazardous
chemicals, and radioactive substances. ASHRAE has also
specified the need to restrict air movement in and between the
various departments and gives different temperature and
humidity requirements.
There also needs to be special
precautions if construction is being done in healthcare
facilities. For example, there should be dust-tight barriers
and negative pressure in the area being worked on so that
contaminants do not spread to other parts of the building.
References
- Quayle C. Air scare. Health
Facilities Management. 1997;10(6):22-30.
- O'Neal C. Infection control;
Keeping diseases at bay a full-time effort for healthcare
professionals. The Fort Worth Star Telegram. September 24,
2000.
- Sepkowitz KA. AIDS,
tuberculosis, and the healthcare worker. Clin Infect Dis.
1995;20:232-242.
- Middelraad P. Designing for
better health. Occupational Health and Safety. 1998
May:74-9.
- Martone WJ, Jarvis WR,
Culver DH, Haley RW. Incidence and nature of endemic and
epidemic nosocomial infections. In Hospital Infections,
J.V. Bennett and P.S. Brachman, editors, Boston: Little,
Brown, and Co. 1992:577-596.
- Simmons RB, Price DL, Noble
JA, Crow SA, Ahearn DG. Fungal colonization of air filters
from hospitals. AIHA Journal. 1997;58:900-904.
- Brownson K. Breathing
hospital air can make you sick. Health Care Manager.
1999;18(2):65-72.
- Turjanmas K. Incidence of
immediate allergy to latex gloves in hospital personnel.
Contact Dermatitis. 1987;17:270-5.
- Arellano R, Bradley J,
Sussman G. Prevalence of latex sensitization among
hospital physicians occupationally exposed to latex
gloves. Anesthesiology. 1992;77:905-8.
- Morton J. NHS Hospitals join
latex balloon ban. Omaha World-Herald. December 4, 2000:1.
- Fairley J. Don't get taken
by the cleaners! Nursing Homes. 1995;44(8):14-17.
- Sutherland L. Shop smart.
Health Facilities Management. 2000;13(9):33-6.
- Hermans R. Searching for an
IAQ cure. Consulting-Specifying Engineer. 1998 Sept:46-50